NEW New report: Invalid click rate benchmarks of 85,000 Google accountsCompare yours here
New report: Invalid Click Rate Benchmarks
  • Home
  • Articles
  • How to Build a Comprehensive Fraud Prevention Strategy for E-commerce Businesses

How to Build a Comprehensive Fraud Prevention Strategy for E-commerce Businesses

Cyber fraud is the tax no e-commerce brand wants to pay. Yet it’s everywhere. For every $1 lost to fraud, merchants eat $3 in total costs once you factor in chargebacks, lost inventory, and wasted marketing spend.

But you don’t have to accept fraud as a cost of doing business. With the right fraud prevention strategy, you can block bad actors, protect your revenue, and give customers a seamless and secure checkout experience.

Why fraud is an e-commerce profit killer

The value of global chargebacks is projected to cost $41.69 billion in 2028, according to a HubSpot report. That’s a 23% increase from 2025, which currently stands at around $33.79 billion.

But, the hidden costs hit even harder.

Every fraudulent transaction sets off a chain reaction:

  1. You lose the sale.
  2. You lose the product.
  3. You get hit with chargeback fees.
  4. Your payment processor raises your rates or, worse, flags your business as high risk.

And fraud doesn’t stop at checkout. Many stores also lose money through click fraud, which involves fake traffic and bots that waste your marketing budget without generating real sales.

Each click on a paid ad that never converts represents wasted spend and distorted data, making it harder to optimize campaigns.

When you add it all up, you lose thousands of dollars. This often leads to your profit margins shrinking faster than you can grow them.

And it doesn’t stop at dollars. Fraud damages trust. Too many chargebacks, and your payment partners won’t want to work with you. Too many false declines (where you accidentally block a legitimate customer), and shoppers won’t return. Either way, your reputation takes the hit.

The anatomy of a smart fraud prevention strategy

To build a comprehensive fraud prevention strategy for your e-commerce business, you need to think of it as a form of asset protection planning.

This means using a multi-layered approach to protect your revenue, inventory, and brand reputation from the constant threat of digital fraud. For example, by blocking fraudulent transactions and preventing account takeovers, you are not just stopping an immediate loss but also safeguarding your business’s long-term financial health and customer trust.

Start with a “risk check”

Risk checks are your first line of defense. They help you spot weaknesses before they turn into fraud losses.

Start mapping your customer journey, from account creation to checkout and returns. Ask: Where could someone slip through the cracks? Common red flags include multiple failed login attempts, mismatched shipping and billing addresses, or huge orders from new customers.

To make risk assessments more effective, focus on these key actions:

  • Combine front-end tools, such as CAPTCHA, with back-end monitoring to filter out bot traffic.
  • Set financial transaction thresholds that automatically trigger manual review.
  • Use geolocation checks to spot orders from regions where you don’t usually sell.

Tech that spots fraud before it hits

Manual review can only get you so far. Today’s fraudsters use tools, social engineering, data breaches, and automated scripts to scale their attacks. And they move fast. The only way to keep pace is with just as smart technology.

AI-powered fraud detection systems can flag suspicious behavior in real time, analyze transaction patterns across thousands of data points, and adapt as fraudsters devise new ways to exploit vulnerabilities.

Click fraud protection tools are equally critical to help prevent fraud. These systems will monitor your paid advertising traffic to identify and block bot clicks, competitors, and invalid traffic sources before they drain your marketing budget.

Advanced click fraud detection uses IP tracking, behavioral analysis, and machine learning to distinguish genuine customers from automated attacks, ensuring your ad spend reaches real potential buyers.

There are other digital tools, like device fingerprinting and velocity checks, image recognition, and intrusion detection systems. These add another layer by identifying abnormal activity, such as too many purchases in a short time frame or logins from unusual locations.

If you’re considering fraud detection technology, here are steps you can take:

  • Run “mystery shopper” tests on your own checkout to spot weak spots in real time.
  • Compare order data against known fraud databases or blacklists.
  • Segment customers by risk level (e.g., new vs. repeat buyers) and adjust your checks accordingly.

Protect your payments

Payment fraud doesn’t just result in lost revenue. It can also damage customer trust, tie up cash flow, and potentially increase chargeback fees.

While tools like fraud detection software and strong customer authentication are essential, the type of payment card you use on the business side can also make a difference.

One way to add an extra layer of protection is to use a secure business credit card that includes built-in fraud alerts, purchase protection, and zero-liability policies.

With these cards, any unauthorized charges are flagged quickly, giving you more time to respond and reducing the financial impact on your business. They can also simplify chargeback disputes, since many issuers provide dedicated merchant support and faster resolution processes.

Beyond cards, merchants should also consider adopting payment security protocols, such as 3D Secure 2.0, tokenization, and encryption. These measures make it significantly harder for fraudsters to exploit stolen credentials, ensuring your checkout process remains safe without driving away legitimate customers.

Here are some proven ways to strengthen payment security:

  • Require step-up authentication (like one-time passwords) for high-value orders.
  • Partner with banks that offer dispute resolution support.
  • Monitor declined transactions to catch patterns that suggest card testing attacks.

Policy is power

Policies might not sound exciting, but they’re one of the most effective fraud deterrents you can deploy. 

Clear, well-enforced return and refund policies make it more difficult for scammers to exploit loopholes, such as “friendly fraud” or fake returns. For example, you can require proof of purchase, limit return windows, and charge restocking fees on certain products. All of these can help reduce fraudulent claims.

These policies also help when disputes do arise. They provide you with documented proof to present to payment processors or bank accounts during chargeback investigations. 

The key is finding the balance: policies need to be protective enough to block abuse, but still flexible enough for a positive customer experience.

Other policy updates worth considering:

  • Flag customers who repeatedly return high-value items and review their accounts.
  • Offer store credit instead of cash refunds for certain categories.
  • Require customers to cover return shipping on discounted or promotional items.

Train your team (and your customers)

Even the best fraud tools can’t replace human judgment. Your frontline staff, whether in customer service, order fulfillment, or finance, should know how to quickly recognize suspicious activity and escalate issues.

Training sessions that cover red flags, phishing risks, and chargeback procedures pay off big in avoided financial losses.

On the customer side, education builds trust and reduces vulnerability. Reminders like encouraging shoppers to enable two-factor authentication, avoid reusing passwords, and check their statements regularly go a long way.

Fraud prevention is a partnership. When both your team and your customers know what to look for, fraudsters have a much harder time getting through.

Here’s how to make fraud awareness stick:

  • Create an escalation flowchart so employees know exactly what to do when they suspect fraud.
  • Run internal “fraud drills” to test staff readiness under pressure.
  • Add customer reminders about security (like password resets or suspicious activity alerts) directly in order confirmation emails.

Fraud prevention as part of customer experience

Fraud prevention directly impacts how customers interact with your store and whether they convert. A secure but seamless checkout builds confidence. And clunky steps or false declines frustrate shoppers and cut into revenue. To keep protection strong without disrupting the buyer experience, put these practices in place:
  • Use invisible checks where possible: Device fingerprinting, tokenization, and risk scoring can run in the background without slowing down the checkout process.
  • Reserve step-up authentication for high-risk orders: A one-time password or biometric prompt works well for unusually large purchases or new customer accounts, but keeps the flow fast for trusted buyers.
  • Be transparent: When extra verification is necessary, explain that the measure protects both the customer and the business. A message at checkout goes a long way toward reducing frustration.
  • Track false declines: Monitor how often legitimate customers are blocked and adjust rules to balance security and convenience.

Stay ahead of the fraud curve

Fraudsters often seek vulnerabilities in cloud systems. There are “Cloud Security Posture Management” tools (CSPM tools for short), which allow you to automate security checks, reduce human error, and generally keep your e-commerce environment more resilient.

But cloud security is just one piece of the future-proofing puzzle. Fraud evolves fast. Synthetic identities, account takeovers, and “Buy-Now, Pay-Later” (BNPL) scams are becoming more common every year.

If your strategy stands still, you’ll always be playing catch up.

Here’s how you can stay a step ahead:

  • Tap into fraud intelligence networks: Learn from shared data consortia and threat feeds that provide real-time automated monitoring. This can help you detect emerging attack methods before they hit your store.
  • Test your defenses regularly: Run simulated fraud attacks against your own systems to uncover blind spots.
  • Keep policies flexible: Update return rules, checkout flows, and authentication processes as new fraud patterns appear, instead of waiting until losses pile up.
  • Invest in automation: Manual fraud review can’t keep pace with high-volume attacks. Improving your review methods assisted by artificial intelligence (AI) and machine learning (ML) helps you automate alerts, flag, and prevent fraud. This frees your team to focus on complex cases.
  • Watch payment trends: As new payment methods like digital wallets or BNPL rise, so do their unique fraud risks. Building safeguards early prevents bigger headaches later.

Keep your store secure, your customers safer with Fraud Blocker

A comprehensive fraud prevention strategy strengthens customer trust, protects your revenue, and positions your small business for sustainable growth.

Each blocked chargeback, flagged account, and secured payment offers strong risk management while reinforcing your reputation as a reliable place to shop.

The stronger your cybersecurity defenses, the more confident your customers feel. And confidence is what keeps them coming back.

But protecting your store from fraud means looking beyond the checkout page. Every dollar you save from wasted ads is a dollar you can reinvest into campaigns that reach real customers.

If you’re ready to strengthen your defenses from checkout to campaign spend, start with Fraud Blocker and put wasted ad dollars back into driving growth. Begin your free trial today.

[This post was authored by Fraud Blocker’s editorial team.]

More from Fraud Blocker